Analyst Tracker/Matthew Carletti

Matthew Carletti

Q: How accurate are Matthew Carletti's stock ratings?

About 61% of Matthew's ratings were profitable over a one-year hold, with an average return of +13.0% per rating, measured by 13Foresight from historical prices.

Q: How is Matthew ranked?

Matthew Carletti is ranked #541 on 13Foresight, scored on hit rate, average return versus the market, and number of calls.

Citizens JMP

Wall Street Analyst

★★★★☆

#541

on 13Foresight · ranked by our own returns

61%

Success Rate

+13.0%

Average Return

30 of 49 calls profitable · +58.8% vs benchmark

Time Frame ⓘ

1 Yr 2 Yr 3 Yr 5 Yr

Compared To ⓘ

S&P 500 (SPY)

📈 Across the calls we could measure, roughly 61% of Matthew Carletti's ratings turned a profit when each position was held for 1 year — averaging +13.0% per rating. These figures are computed by 13Foresight from historical prices, not supplied by the analyst.

Rating Distribution

52 Buy 5 Hold 0 Sell

Matthew's Stock Coverage 39 ratings · 2026-08-19

Company	Date	Position	Consensus ⓘ	Price Target ⓘ	1-Yr Return	vs S&P 500 ⓘ
HG Hamilton Insurance Group, Ltd. Class B	Aug 07, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy -1.1% avg upside 9 analysts	$42.00 19.17% Upside	-0.4%	·
HCI HCI Group	Aug 07, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy +8.8% avg upside 8 analysts	$265.00 43.13% Upside	-2.3%	·
LIFE Ethos Technologies Inc. Class A	Aug 04, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy -5.4% avg upside 12 analysts	$33.00 2.90% Downside	+23.0%	·
SLDE Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc.	Jul 30, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy +13.8% avg upside 6 analysts	$27.00 21.34% Upside	+7.1%	·
THG Hanover Insurance	Jul 29, 2026	BUY	Buy -4.9% avg upside 9 analysts	$240.00 8.05% Upside	-3.0%	·
BRO Brown & Brown	Jul 10, 2026	BUY	Hold +10.5% avg upside 25 analysts	$78.00 12.52% Upside	+4.5%	·
PLGO Pelagos Insurance Capital	Jul 10, 2026	BUY	Hold -3.8% avg upside 12 analysts	$28.00 18.79% Upside	-4.9%	·
CB Chubb	Jul 10, 2026	BUY	Buy -7.6% avg upside 33 analysts	$400.00 15.85% Upside	-1.2%	·
AII American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.	May 13, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy +5.3% avg upside 7 analysts	$25.00 0.94% Downside	+42.2%	·
JRVR James River Group	May 05, 2026	HOLD	Sell +361.5% avg upside 7 analysts	—	-10.8%	·
LMND Lemonade	Apr 30, 2026	BUY	Hold -7.8% avg upside 22 analysts	$80.00 59.63% Upside	-7.1%	·
AMSF Amerisafe	Apr 13, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy +98.5% avg upside 4 analysts	$45.00 69.55% Upside	-16.7%	·
ARX Accelerant Holdings Class A	Apr 13, 2026	BUY	Buy +2.9% avg upside 12 analysts	$17.00 13.01% Downside	+52.6%	·
BOW Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc.	Apr 13, 2026	BUY	Buy +0.7% avg upside 7 analysts	$35.00 4.55% Upside	+36.7%	·
GSHD GooseHead Insurance	Apr 13, 2026	BUY	Buy +14.8% avg upside 15 analysts	$100.00 54.35% Upside	+58.2%	·
KMPR Kemper	Feb 05, 2026	HOLD	Buy +149.2% avg upside 8 analysts	—	-16.3%	·
STC Stewart Information Services	Feb 02, 2026	BUY	Strong Buy +5.7% avg upside 6 analysts	$80.00 17.72% Upside	-2.4%	·
SKWD Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc.	Dec 04, 2025	BUY	Strong Buy +11.6% avg upside 15 analysts	$80.00 36.88% Upside	+25.8%	·
XZO Exzeo Group, Inc.	Dec 01, 2025	BUY	Strong Buy +67.2% avg upside 3 analysts	$27.00 67.20% Upside	-19.4%	·
HIPO Hippo Holdings	Oct 14, 2025	BUY	Strong Buy -2.8% avg upside 9 analysts	$45.00 36.52% Upside	-7.1%	·
ACGL Arch Capital Group	Oct 14, 2025	BUY	Buy +9.7% avg upside 26 analysts	$125.00 26.43% Upside	+6.5%	·
HGTY Hagerty Inc Class A	Oct 01, 2025	BUY	Buy +12.0% avg upside 9 analysts	$15.00 17.03% Upside	+8.5%	·
HRTG Heritage Insurance Holdings	Aug 28, 2025	HOLD	Buy -14.3% avg upside 4 analysts	—	+51.1%	·
RLI RLI	Aug 28, 2025	HOLD	Hold +28.9% avg upside 14 analysts	—	+1.1%	·
KNSL Kinsale Capital Group	Jul 25, 2025	HOLD	Hold -1.9% avg upside 16 analysts	—	-26.7%	·
TRV Travelers Companies	Jul 21, 2025	HOLD	Hold -12.6% avg upside 33 analysts	—	+42.6%	·
HMN Horace Mann Educators	May 19, 2025	HOLD	Buy -2.8% avg upside 6 analysts	—	+8.4%	·
PLMR Palomar Holdings	May 06, 2025	HOLD	Strong Buy +12.7% avg upside 11 analysts	—	-29.2%	·
RNR Renaissancere Holdings	Apr 24, 2025	HOLD	Buy -4.8% avg upside 25 analysts	—	+36.4%	·
ROOT Root	Feb 27, 2025	HOLD	Hold -8.8% avg upside 18 analysts	—	-58.1%	·
EIG Employers Holdings	Feb 21, 2025	HOLD	Buy +8.5% avg upside 4 analysts	—	-17.7%	·
RYAN Ryan Specialty Group	Feb 21, 2025	HOLD	Buy +25.7% avg upside 24 analysts	—	-36.4%	·
AXS Axis Capital	Feb 03, 2025	HOLD	Buy +10.7% avg upside 16 analysts	—	+17.3%	·
SIGI Selective Insurance Group	Jan 30, 2025	HOLD	Hold +3.5% avg upside 10 analysts	—	+4.3%	·
ORI Old Republic International	Jan 23, 2025	HOLD	Buy -2.3% avg upside 3 analysts	—	+13.9%	·
ALL Allstate	Feb 21, 2023	HOLD	Buy -14.5% avg upside 36 analysts	—	+22.0%	·
ACIC American Coastal Insurance	Aug 01, 2022	HOLD	Buy +18.6% avg upside 5 analysts	—	+388.2%	·
UBER Uber Technologies	Oct 09, 2019	BUY	Strong Buy +23.6% avg upside 65 analysts	$50.00 32.94% Downside	+28.2%	·
KG Kestrel Group	May 15, 2018	HOLD	Buy -30.1% avg upside 4 analysts	$8.00 0.11% Upside	-90.2%	·

🔒 34 more ratings — with price targets, crowd consensus and our measured returns.

Free account unlocks every analyst's full coverage table.

Matthew Carletti — Frequently Asked Questions

How accurate are Matthew Carletti's stock ratings?

Based on the calls 13Foresight could measure, about 61% of Matthew's ratings were profitable over a one-year hold, with an average return of +13.0% per rating, or +69.4% versus the S&P 500. We score every analyst the same way, from historical prices. Each return is measured in the stock's own trading currency, so for non-US listings the S&P 500 comparison leaves out currency moves.

How is Matthew ranked on 13Foresight?

Matthew Carletti is currently ranked #541 with a 4-star rating. Our rank blends hit rate, average return versus the market, and how many calls we have to judge — so a long, consistent record outweighs a few lucky picks. It is our own calculation, updated daily.

Which stocks does Matthew cover?

Matthew most recently has ratings on HG, HCI, LIFE, SLDE, THG, BRO, PLGO, CB, AII, JRVR, LMND, AMSF and 27 more. See the full coverage table above for positions, price targets and our measured returns.

Where can I see other analyst ratings?

Browse the full analyst leaderboard to compare Wall Street analysts ranked by their measured performance, success rate and average return.

Disclaimer: 13Foresight compiles analyst ratings and price targets from publicly available sources. Performance metrics, rankings and star ratings shown here are calculated independently by 13Foresight from historical market prices and may differ from figures published elsewhere. This information may be incomplete, delayed or inaccurate, is provided for research and informational purposes only, and is not investment advice. The underlying ratings and opinions are those of the respective analysts and their firms; 13Foresight accepts no liability for any decisions made based on this data.

Matthew Carletti

Rating Distribution

Welcome to 13Foresight!