Live Analyst Rating Changes 1652 upgrades, downgrades & price-target moves · freshest Wall Street data, updated daily View live feed →
Analyst Tracker/Matthew Smith, CFA
STIF
Matthew Smith, CFA
Stifel Nicolaus
Wall Street Analyst
★★★☆☆
#1507
on 13Foresight · ranked by our own returns
43%
Success Rate
-0.8%
Average Return
10 of 23 calls profitable · -5.9% vs benchmark
📈 Across the calls we could measure, roughly 43% of Matthew Smith, CFA's ratings turned a profit when each position was held for 1 year — averaging -0.8% per rating. These figures are computed by 13Foresight from historical prices, not supplied by the analyst.

Rating Distribution

81 Buy 55 Hold 0 Sell
Matthew's Stock Coverage 21 ratings · 2026-06-22
Company Date Position Consensus ⓘ Price Target ⓘ 1-Yr Return
SJM
JM Smucker
 Jun 10, 2026 HOLD Buy
+12.5% avg upside
27 analysts
$115.00
3.80% Upside
 -3.5%
CPB
Campbell Soup
 Jun 09, 2026 HOLD Sell
+21.7% avg upside
28 analysts
$20.00
5.38% Downside
 -4.6%
POST
Post Holdings
 May 11, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+26.3% avg upside
12 analysts
$130.00
47.01% Upside
 -11.5%
MNST
Monster Beverage
 May 08, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
-6.5% avg upside
28 analysts
$90.00
1.50% Downside
 +6.0%
WEST
Westrock Coffee
 May 08, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+2.4% avg upside
7 analysts
$8.00
11.41% Downside
 +15.0%
VITL
Vital Farms
 May 08, 2026 HOLD Buy
+79.6% avg upside
15 analysts
$10.00
3.85% Downside
 +16.4%
FRPT
Freshpet
 May 07, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+56.9% avg upside
21 analysts
$66.00
19.93% Upside
 -8.9%
KHC
Kraft Heinz
 May 07, 2026 HOLD Hold
+46.9% avg upside
33 analysts
$26.00
13.87% Upside
 +3.3%
BRBR
BellRing Brands
 May 06, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+154.4% avg upside
17 analysts
$14.00
47.98% Upside
 -13.2%
MO
Altria Group
 May 01, 2026 BUY Hold
-9.9% avg upside
23 analysts
$77.00
11.49% Upside
 -5.9%
HSY
The Hershey Company
 May 01, 2026 HOLD Buy
+12.5% avg upside
31 analysts
$215.00
24.64% Upside
 -4.6%
MDLZ
Mondelez International
 Apr 29, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+12.4% avg upside
30 analysts
$68.00
13.06% Upside
 -1.5%
PM
Philip Morris
 Apr 23, 2026 BUY Buy
-4.2% avg upside
22 analysts
$195.00
9.28% Upside
 +6.1%
GIS
General Mills
 Apr 21, 2026 BUY Hold
+36.0% avg upside
29 analysts
$40.00
19.76% Upside
 -4.7%
CAG
Conagra Brands
 Apr 21, 2026 HOLD Hold
+22.2% avg upside
19 analysts
$15.00
13.62% Upside
 -7.8%
SMPL
Simply Good Foods
 Apr 10, 2026 BUY Buy
+72.2% avg upside
15 analysts
$20.00
58.27% Upside
 +11.3%
LW
Lamb Weston Holdings
 Apr 02, 2026 HOLD Buy
+27.5% avg upside
16 analysts
$45.00
0.14% Downside
 +12.9%
MKC
McCormick & Company
 Apr 01, 2026 HOLD Buy
+46.3% avg upside
15 analysts
$55.00
17.96% Upside
 -2.7%
CELH
Celsius Holdings
 Feb 27, 2026 BUY Buy
+87.4% avg upside
24 analysts
$62.00
101.36% Upside
 -43.3%
HAIN
Hain Celestial
 Feb 10, 2026 HOLD Buy
+1334.2% avg upside
20 analysts
$1.00
65.13% Upside
 -11.3%
SIMPQ
Simply
 Jul 10, 2025 BUY Buy
+34694373.2% avg upside
10 analysts
$38.00
37999899.98% Upside
 ·
🔒 16 more ratings — with price targets, crowd consensus and our measured returns.
Sign in free to unlock See Pro plans
Free account unlocks every analyst's full coverage table.
Matthew Smith, CFA — Frequently Asked Questions
How accurate are Matthew Smith, CFA's stock ratings?
Based on the calls 13Foresight could measure, about 43% of Matthew's ratings were profitable over a one-year hold, with an average return of -0.8% per rating, or -6.1% versus the S&P 500. We score every analyst the same way, from historical prices.
How is Matthew ranked on 13Foresight?
Matthew Smith, CFA is currently ranked #1507 with a 3-star rating. Our rank blends hit rate, average return versus the market, and how many calls we have to judge — so a long, consistent record outweighs a few lucky picks. It is our own calculation, updated daily.
Which stocks does Matthew cover?
Matthew most recently has ratings on SJM, CPB, POST, MNST, WEST, VITL, FRPT, KHC, BRBR, MO, HSY, MDLZ and 9 more. See the full coverage table above for positions, price targets and our measured returns.
Where can I see other analyst ratings?
Browse the full analyst leaderboard to compare Wall Street analysts ranked by their measured performance, success rate and average return.

Disclaimer: 13Foresight compiles analyst ratings and price targets from publicly available sources. Performance metrics, rankings and star ratings shown here are calculated independently by 13Foresight from historical market prices and may differ from figures published elsewhere. This information may be incomplete, delayed or inaccurate, is provided for research and informational purposes only, and is not investment advice. The underlying ratings and opinions are those of the respective analysts and their firms; 13Foresight accepts no liability for any decisions made based on this data.